As I mentioned in an earlier post, I submitted my September 17th blog post "It's the Economy and Foreign Policy Stupid!" (with a few minor changes) to the editor of the Lansing State Journal. It was published on September 22, 2008 under a different title, "World worried over our election nonsense: Can candidates, voters engage on real issues?" I received a number of positive comments through e-mail and facebook. In the spirit of full disclosure, I have had two detractors; one e-mailed me his concerns and the other sent a letter to the editorial board of the LSJ. In an effort to be fair and balanced, I thought I would give them the space in my blog for their opinion.
Having just read your opinion piece about our country's falling image abroad, I urge you to come home. Unless you find a way to balance your surface complaints about the flaws in our country's politics with a healthy respect for the overall value of the system, your apologetic demeanor can only reinforce the poorly-formed views of others.
Have you ever considered asking people to name a political system that has provided more individual freedoms to succeed and - yes - to fail? Can you think of a way to prevent failures without undermining the freedom to take the risks necessary to succeed? Do you recognize that mistakes will be made? Do you place accountability on the fact that mistakes were made instead of on whether lessons learned help fine tune the system?
Our system is imperfect, it is inefficient, and - combined with irresponsible journalism - it can be extremely shallow during major elections. These factual observations do not diminish my personal opinion that, warts and all, I can't think of a better system anywhere in the world.
I, too, travel internationally - but for business. I, too, have heard the same type of angst about the US. Sometimes I think people simply repeated the surface criticisms they read in the news just to get my view. Instead of apologizing for my country - or defending her - I ask people to take a broader view of the United States, the good with the imperfect today, and over time. In statistics, we call this a representative sample. Instead of being embarrassed by my country, I am able to defend her by simply asking people to consider a broader view than a minute example ot two from current events.
There are a lot of things our country needs to do to improve. But having a roving apologist is not one of them.
I responded to Bob via an e-mail because I felt he missed the point of my editorial.
Thank you for your response to my editorial. I guess we do not see eye to eye on the issues. I can appreciate that you think our foreign policy and economic policy are on the right track. I simply disagree (the beauty of democracy). Asking the media to focus on global issues rather than the ones they have since the conventions is because I care about where we are headed as a nation. I believe in our democracy and I have actively participated in it on many levels. I don't know if I would call asking my fellow citizens to achieve more in order to better our global position a "roving apologist." The term that comes to mind is an engaged citizen but imagine we would disagree with that as well. Anyways, all the best. Sam
The next detractor came from a small township right outside of Lansing. I think she made my case quite brilliantly that many Americans have a narrow perspective on our role and impact on the global stage. This is good example of why there is still 25% of Americans who feel we are on the right track and support the President.
The incredible success of capitalism and democracy in America just burns up those, both here and abroad, who want socialism to succeed. If America was such a bad place, we wouldn't have long lines of "the world's" people waiting to be Americans, nor so many sneaking in illegally. People vote with their feet.
A word to "the world": no criticizing America and then sticking out your hands for our money and our military.
This is the most generous and big-hearted nation on Earth. It shares its wealth, adopts the world's children and sends our children to protect the world. No amount of biased, liberal, America-hating "journalism" is going to change that fact. God bless America!
Carol
Delta Township
Anyway, I wanted to share these two perspectives with you because they have had me chuckling for the past few days. A roving apologist and an "American hating" journalist all in the same week. It is my Best Week Ever!
I almost "suspended" my trip around the world last week to head to Washington to work on the economic bailout proposal. I am glad I didn't go now because it would have made me look real foolish!
Instead, I am on alert this week because I might be contacted if Putin rears his head. I know what you are thinking, "Sam doesn't even live near Russia" but since I drank vodka at a Russian wedding this summer, my advice is in demand by both candidates.
Be happy only 35 more days of this nonsense!

